Sunday, 9 December 2012

Scotland's Free Tuition Scam

Yes. That's right. Scotland's student funding model is fundamentally disingenuous. The profoundly political decision to impose no notional or actual levy on the tuition component of University study for Scottish domiciled students is a move which only serves to help those with relatively affluent parents. This might seem anathema to the great body of "progressives" within Scotland, but it's true. And here is why.

Student debt is not real debt in the UK. Under both the Scottish system (where you receive a student loan from the Student Award Agency for Scotland) and the English system (where you receive a student loan from Student Finance England) you are given that support on fundamentally different terms from a normal loan. You repay in proportion to your income, pay nothing for earnings under a certain threshold, and your debt is written-off by SAAS or the SLC after a fixed number of years. The particulars are as follows:

So it's not a real debt in the sense that it will not affect your credit rating (or eligibility from a mortgage). It is recovered from you in a very similar way to income tax, and might be seen as somewhat of a time and contributions limited graduate tax.

What about maintenance debt?

The next thing to look at is how much debt students will actually take on. The common component of debt north and south of the border is maintenance debt, which is the component of maintenance support that is a loan, rather than a grant. The two schemes offer broadly similar levels of support. The only significant differences are that bursary support in Scotland falls away far more sharply (no bursary support for those from households with incomes higher than £35kpa, compared to the English system, which hits that cliff at £42kpa), and that English loan support for those from high-earner families (more than £55kpa) is noticeably lower.

There is also a slight additional weighting for students studying in London, which over three years would add about £6.5k to the maintenance component of the total debt owed to the Student Loans Company. I have included two tables below, the first coming from the SAAS website, and the second is from (but is a derivative of a table from the Student Finance England website) which demonstrate the broad equivalence of the two maintenance schemes.

There are several things to take into account at this stage. English Universities typically operate 3-year undergraduate courses, whereas Scottish Universities operate 4-year programmes. The typical maintenance debt arising from being a Scottish student at a Scottish University, therefore, will be higher than for an English domiciled student in an English University. A Scottish student will accrue somewhere between £18k and £22k debt in maintenance, whereas an English student will accrue anything between £10.5k-£16k in maintenance debt.

What about tuition debt?

The next step is to consider the impact of tuition debt. English Universities may charge anything between £6kpa and £9kpa for their courses. This adds between £18k and £27k to a three-year undergraduate debt. For generosity of comparison, we will assume £9k fees across the board, giving the typical debt on graduate in England a total of between £37.5k and £43k. Superficially this seems like a massive difference. Notionally, English domiciled students going to English Universities are in twice as much debt as their Scottish counterparts. But what do they actually pay back?

This is the point when our first table really begins to matter. Those going through the Scottish loans system have to start making contributions back when they are earning considerably less money, and under the new funding arrangements, will only have their remaining debt written off after 35 years, compared to the 30 under the new English scheme.

So what do people actually repay?

For a Scottish graduate, if they earn about £16k as their starting salary, and their average salary over 35 years is about £22k over the course of 35 years (in today's money), they will have to pay back their student loan virtually in its entirety over that period. In other words, they will have paid about £18-22k to the SLC in exchange for their whole university experience. Virtually every student earning over, on average, £22kpa in Scotland will repay their loan in full. The only meaningful difference is that higher earners will pay it off a lot more quickly. By way of example, someone with 35-year salary average of about £35k in today's money will have paid off their student loan within 11-12 years.

For an English graduate that earns the same amount, they will start paying their loan back a lot later (because of the higher repayment threshold) and when they do, their payments will be smaller. This, combined with the 30-year write-off, makes it even less likely that an English graduate will repay their loan in full. If they earned the same amount as the low-earning graduate above (£16k starting salary, £22k career average) they would repay... £2700 in today's money. Yes. That's right. About 13.5% of what the Scottish graduate pays. The amount that is actually repaid then continues to rise the more successful the graduate is.

The tipping point (i.e. the point at which the two schemes lead to you actually paying back roughly the same amount) is when someone has 30-35 year average earnings of about £28500 in today's money, or roughly the equivalent of someone who gets a career starting salary of £22k. From that point onwards, it is absolutely true to say that English students at English Universities will be paying more. The peak cost under the English system will fall on earners with career average salaries at around £50k in today's prices, and they will pay about £75-80k towards the cost of their education if they took a £9kpa course.

But what can we learn from this?

What does and doesn't matter?

There are a number of important lessons we can draw from this comparison. Firstly, it is virtually irrelevant for modest graduate earners (those earning up to £28500) whether they are or are not charged tuition fees. The fact that maintenance loans and tuitions fees are combined under the same loan for repayment purposes means that one type of debt is indistinguishable from the other.

It also means that the terms of repayment matter a lot for all income brackets. The level of maintenance support north and south of the border is broadly equivalent in terms of the up-front support it gives to students to live-off. It is certainly the case that the schemes are not identical, and that both countries (but especially England) could show greater regard to the difference in living costs from city to city. What we see though, is that maintenance delivery has a much bigger impact on what Scottish students have to pay back than it does for English students.

This matters from the perspective of allocation of resources as well, however. In both absolute and relative terms, Scotland's system demands a greater direct contribution from graduates earning typical graduate salaries. This can be attributed almost exclusively to the repayment threshold that is applied, but also to some extent to the 35-year write-off period (for extremely low-earners). Further, we should consider what kind of student is most likely to take out a maintenance loan in the first place.

Who is most affected by debt attaching to maintenance rather than fees?

Students more likely to take out maintenance loans are those who a) come from less affluent families b) are living away from home and c) do not have an alternative source of revenue. Though it is certainly true that the loan component of the maintenance payment is lower for lower earners (under both systems) it is only marginally so. In practice, this means that the children of the affluent in Scotland are less likely to need or seek support from the loans system in the first place, and in consequence will be called upon to contribute absolutely nothing towards its upkeep over and above the general taxation burden they face, which is identical north and south of the border.

Now clearly it's a bit of a false economy even if these affluent students continue to take out these loans. One classic strategy of students was to take out the maximum (interest-free) loan and to place it in a high-interest savings account before repaying in full without penalty. That scheme is broadly circumvented nowadays by very low savings rates and in England by the closer-to-commercial interest rates on the loan amount, but what they're paying back is broadly what they took in terms of maintenance.

Redistribution: when does more of it happen?

Self-styled progressives, left-wingers, social liberals etc. should ask themselves whether such a system really improves access and tackles inequality to a meaningful extent. The Scottish student support system, particularly now that the SNP have reduced the bursary component, is less redistributive than the English student support system. By charging fees, you do two things. Firstly, you make it far more likely that the children of the affluent will tie themselves into the contribution system. They are more likely to take the calculated gamble that their earnings post graduation will not be high enough to make it worth their while having their parents pay it up-front. If they are, by the time they notice, they'll be sufficiently affluent as it will make little material difference to them. Secondly, by charging above RPI inflation for higher earners, you facilitate a far greater redistributive effect, lowering the burden for those from disadvantaged backgrounds and low graduate earners. This has the effect of making the disadvantaged not simply better-off in terms of the education you provide them, but also in raw cash-terms as well, given their maintenance benefit far exceeds what they pay back in terms of loans.

What are our real options to increase access to University?

University of Glasgow
The real lesson in this, however, is that access to education is not determined by the notional price-tag of that education, but by the manner in which that burden is levied upon society. For as long as we tolerate part of student maintenance taking the form of a loan, we have no principled objection to university tuition fees. There is often a call for a return to grants-only systems, but we have to bear in mind that they were possible back in an era when 5-10% of school-leavers went to University. Now that figure is closer to 40-45%. If we are serious about removing all loan components from tertiary education, we have to explain, in explicit economic terms, how we are going to pay for the maintenance of that extra 30-40% of school-leavers. This system also has no regard to the relative lack of part-time and post-graduate state support in Scotland compared to England, funded out of fees. Post-graduate degrees, in particular, receive very little (if any) state loan support, meaning that they are only accessible to those who are affluent or can find an external source of support. Our real options are to increase taxation yield (successfully) or to reallocate considerable expenditure from elsewhere.

Our choice is that, or that we admit considerably fewer students to University. Alas that probably is not a silver bullet either. Unlike 30-40 years ago, we no longer have the option available to us to allow a large number of school-leavers to go straight into apprenticeships or work. As things stand youth unemployment is considerably higher than unemployment as a whole. The demand is increasingly for skilled workers, and that means preserving more of our Further Education Colleges for those who cannot or do not want to entertain an academic or professional career.

Short of a revolutionary and mass-scale redistribution of wealth of the like we have never seen, the most progressive option available to us seems to be to ask successful University graduates to contribute more over and above our progressive tax system. It is in this context that free undergraduate tuition for Scots domiciles is a con. Not only does it not actually make University cheaper for our students, but it also makes it less accessible to the disadvantaged than could be achieved with a tuition-based funding model.


  1. Great article. Very well written and making some salient points. This should be distributed as widely as possible particularly among the faux left middle-class nationalists.

    Keep up the good work.

  2. So if high fees in England are so great, why did the Lib Dems campaign on a solemn promise of keeping them at a third of their current level?

    1. Cynical electioneering. I opposed it at the time. Always have done. And now Labour in England and the SNP up here are doing exactly the same thing: politicking with the tuition fee level when that's not the important part of the system that determines what graduates actually pay.

  3. Why presume they'd seen the analysis. Plus they had no earthly reason to suppose they'd be anywhere near whitehall.

  4. So those who pay most are those who are domiciled in Scotland, study in England and take out a loan for both fees and maintenance?

    1. That would be correct. Entirely in consequence of the Scottish Government choosing to set-up a loans repayment system with such a low repayment threshold. They could raise that threshold if they introduced tuition fees, which would transfer more of the burden for higher education towards high-earning Scottish graduates.

  5. Really good, informative, piece Graeme.

  6. I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people. Clean Eat Guide

  7. I'm writing on this topic these days, 먹튀검증, but I have stopped writing because there is no reference material. Then I accidentally found your article. I can refer to a variety of materials, so I think the work I was preparing will work! Thank you for your efforts.

  8. First of all, thank you for letting me see this information. I think this article can give me a lot of inspiration. I would appreciate 바둑이사이트 if you could post more good contents in the future.

  9. I'm writing on this topic these days, , but I have stopped writing because there is no reference material. Then I accidentally found your article. I can refer to a variety of materials, so I think the work I was preparing will work! Thank you for your efforts. 토토사이트

  10. Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing. gold pendant necklace

  11. Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! best yoga mats 2017

  12. Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share. best yoga mat for sweaty hands

  13. As I am looking at your writing, 온라인바둑이 I regret being unable to do outdoor activities due to Corona 19, and I miss my old daily life. If you also miss the daily life of those days, would you please visit my site once? My site is a site where I post about photos and daily life when I was free.

  14. I have to look for goals with essential information on given point and offer them to instructor our inclination and the article. live22 mobile

  15. I like the valuable info in your articles. I'll bookmark your blog and check again here regularly. I'll learn plenty of new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next! Regards houses for sale in burnley under £20000

  16. wow, great, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your site by google, learned a lot, now i’m a bit clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also add rss. keep us updated. houses for sale in burnley

  17. เครื่องหมายด้านในเกม สล็อตออนไลน์ ที่ควรจะทราบก่อนไปสู่การเล่นพนัน
    เกม สล็อต เป็นเกมที่ประกอบไปด้วยส่วนของรีลเกม ไลน์พนัน รูปภาพเรื่องราวของเกมหรือเรียกว่าต้นแบบเกม แล้วก็เครื่องหมายของเกมซึ่งจะเป็นภาพที่สอดคล้องกับต้นแบบเกม และก็อาจจะเป็นไปได้ว่าจะมีการเสริมภาพอื่นๆเข้ามาเพื่อทำให้เครื่องหมายของเกมมีความมากมายเพิ่มมากขึ้นนั้นเอง สำหรับการเข้าเล่นพนันแต่ละครั้งนักเล่นการพนันจำนวนมากบางทีอาจจะมิได้พอใจหรือให้ความเอาใจใส่กับเครื่องหมายเกมกันเยอะแค่ไหน เพราะว่าส่วนให้จะพึงพอใจที่อัตราการชำระเงินรางวัลของเกมแต่ละเกมมากยิ่งกว่า

    จุดสำคัญของเครื่องหมายข้างในเกม SLOT
    ภาพเครื่องหมายในเกม สล็อตออนไลน์ เป็นตัวระบุเงินรางวัลของเกม ถ้าเกิดคุณทดลองเปิดเข้าไปมองอัตราการชำระเงินรางวัลของเกม SLOT จะมองเห็นได้ว่าเงินรางวัลของแต่ละรางวัลจะขึ้นกับการจัดลำดับของภาพเครื่องหมายทั้งปวง เงินรางวัลจะมากเพิ่มขึ้นเมื่อภาพเครื่องหมายนั้นเป็นตัวหลักของเกมพนันนั้นๆแล้วก็มีภาพเครื่องหมายพิเศษเสริมเติมเข้ามา เพื่อทำให้ผู้เล่นเข้าถึงฟีพบร์พิเศษของเกมหรือโบนัสของเกมได้ เครื่องหมายด้านในเกม SLOT ก็เลยนับว่ามีความจำเป็นรวมทั้งเป็นตัวระบุเลยว่าคุณจะได้เงินรางวัลอะไรบ้างต่อรอบสำหรับเพื่อการหมุนเล่นเกม

    จุดเด่นของเกม SLOT ที่มีเครื่องหมายนานัปการ
    สำหรับคนใดที่ยังไม่เคยเล่นเกม สล็อต มาก่อนหรือบางทีอาจจะเคยเล่นมาบ้างแต่ว่ายังมิได้เล่นแบบขมักเขม้น บางครั้งก็อาจจะยังไม่เคยรู้ว่าภาพเครื่องหมายเป็นจำนวนมากด้านในเกม SLOT นั้นมีจุดเด่นอยู่มากจริงๆดังต่อไปนี้

    ถ้าหากเกมไหนมีภาพเครื่องหมายมากมายเงินรางวัลของเกมก็จะมากมาย รวมทั้งอาจเริ่มต้นด้วยการจัดลำดับของภาพแค่เพียง 1 ภาพขึ้นไปก็มองเห็นถึงเงินรางวัลกันแล้ว ถ้าหากภาพน้อยเงินรางวัลก็จะไม่ค่อยนานาประการแล้วก็ยากต่อการที่จะหมุนให้มันออกมาเรียงกันได้นั้นเอง

    โดยมากแล้วเกมที่มีเครื่องหมายเยอะมากๆก็จะมากับไลน์พนันไม่น้อยเลยทีเดียวเหมือนกัน เมื่อทั้งยัง 2 อย่างประสานกันแล้วหลังจากนั้นก็มีแต่ว่าจะมีผลให้ผู้เล่นมั่งคั่งแล้วก็มั่งคั่งแค่นั้น ด้วยเหตุว่าไลน์พนันจะเป็นตัวช่วยสำหรับในการทำเงินรางวัลได้มากเพิ่มขึ้นแล้วก็เป็นทางออกที่ทำให้เครื่องหมายสามารถออกมาเรียงกันในแนวหรือแถวแบบไหนก็ได้นั้นเอง

    ภาพเครื่องหมายโดยมากจะเกี่ยวพันกับลักษณะของเกมเป็นการเล่าราวผ่านภาพอีกอย่างหนึ่ง ซึ่งมันทำให้ผู้เล่นได้รู้เรื่องแบบแล้วก็เรื่องราวของเกมเพิ่มมากขึ้น ทั้งมันยังช่วยทำให้ผู้เล่นได้เพลินใจเมื่อเข้าเล่นพนันอยู่ตลอดอีกด้วย

    เป็นไงบ้างสำหรับจุดสำคัญของภาพเครื่องหมายด้านในเกม pgslot จากทาง คาสิโนออนไลน์ ที่พวกเราเอามาฝากกัน คงจะเพียงพอทำให้ผู้คนจำนวนไม่ใช้น้อยที่คิดอย่าจะเล่นเกมพนันจำพวกนี้เข้าใจในเรื่องจุดสำคัญของภาพกันเยอะขึ้นแล้ว และก็อาจจะก่อให้ต้องการเข้าเล่นกันเพิ่มขึ้นเรื่อยๆไปอีกก็ได้เมื่อได้ทราบจะเกมพนันประเภทนี้กันมากขึ้น

  18. I like what you guys are usually up too. This kind of clever work and coverage! Keep up the very good works guys I’ve incorporated you guys to blogroll.

  19. Hurrah, that's what I was looking for, what a material!

    existing here at this website, thanks admin of this web page.

    Feel free to surf to my webpage - 부산오피

  20. เกมเดิมพันระบบออนไลน์ ที่จะตอบสนอง ความต้องการได้อย่างดี ไม่ว่าจะเป็นโปรโมชั่น สมาชิกใหม่ โบนัส การฝากเงิน หรือ การแนะนำเพื่อน ซึ่ง เป็นอีกหนึ่งรูปแบบ การใช้งานที่คุ้มค่ามากสุด เว็บพนันออนไลน์ ที่เปิดให้บริการ ด้วยมาตรฐาน


  21. Register online JC HUAY online free credit for online

  22. 🏆 IPRO356 🏆
    📌 Make money at home with the mobile phone you have. Don't wait ‼
    100,000-baht/month Just refer your friends through your link.
    Go to websit :

  23. เกม pg slot เป็นเกมพนันที่นับว่าเล่นง่ายที่สุดในบรรดาเกมพนันทั้งหมดทั้งปวงของเว็บไซต์พนันออนไลน์ รวมทั้งในความง่ายของมันนั้นก็ยังเต็มไปด้วยเงินรางวัลเกมจำนวนมาก ที่แม้คุณจะไม่เคยเข้าเล่นมาก่อนเลยก็ยังสามารถเล่นทำเงินได้ด้วยเหมือนกัน
    เกม SLOT เป็นเกมพนันประเภทหนึ่งที่ผู้เล่นจำเป็นจะต้องเพิ่มเติมเงินเข้ามายังเว็บไซต์เพื่อใช้เป็นเครดิตสำหรับการเล่นพนัน หรือเรียกกันกล้วยๆว่ามันจะต้องลงทุนก็เลยจะเข้าเล่นทำเงินได้นั้นเอง รวมทั้งเมื่อพวกเราลงทุนไปแล้วสำเร็จผลกำไรจากการลงทุนพวกเราก็มีสิทธิ์ที่จะเบิกเงินทุนและก็กำไรของพวกเราออกมาได้อยู่ตลอด สำหรับคนใดกันที่กลัวว่าเล่นแล้วจะเบิกเงินมิได้ถูกหลอกให้ฝากเงินเข้า ถ้าเกิดเล่นกับเว็บไซต์พวกเราเรื่องเหล่านี้ไม่มีความจำเป็นต้องกลัวเพราะว่าถอนออกได้อย่างแน่แท้ pg slot

  24. Thanks for your marvelous posting! I actually enjoyed reading it, you could be
    a great author.I will remember to bookmark your blog and will
    eventually come back from now on. I want to encourage you to continue your great
    writing, have a nice weekend!


  25. 👑 IPRO356👑
    🔥 Lots of new games
    ✔️ Ready to serve Sports>>Casino>>Slots>>Lottery
    ♠️ Pok Deng 🃏 Baccarat
    ✌🏼 Pei Ying Chub 🎲 Spin and paste
    🍐 The leading succulents
    🔥Deposit-withdrawal with automatic system
    🔥 There is a recipe to give away for free.
    Go to websit :

  26. Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! Play Free slots

  27. Thank you so much for share such a wonderful information and ideas. The author clearly describe all the parts of the article and we can easily understand each and every information. Quality articles is the vital to welcome the clients to pay visit the webpage, that’s what this site is giving. quick fund capital

  28. I can’t imagine how you write these amazing posts, your blog is a great help for us. You are sharing everything which is the best part of this blog. I have learned a lot from your blog and I almost read you’re every post.

  29. I can’t imagine how you write these amazing posts, your blog is a great help for us. You are sharing everything which is the best part of this blog. I have learned a lot from your blog and I almost read you’re every post.

  30. Where did u come up with the information on this posting? I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work

  31. Thank you so much for share such a wonderful information and ideas. The author clearly describe all the parts of the article and we can easily understand each and every information. Quality articles is the vital to welcome the clients to pay visit the webpage, that’s what this site is giving. lemon sour diesel

  32. Are you the one who studies this subject?? I have a headache with this subject.우리카지노Looking at your writing was very helpful.

  33. 바카라사이트3 January 2022 at 04:44

    Looking at this article, I miss the time when I didn't wear a mask. 바카라사이트 Hopefully this corona will end soon. My blog is a blog that mainly posts pictures of daily life before Corona and landscapes at that time. If you want to remember that time again, please visit us.

  34. We are looking for a lot of data on this item. In the meantime, this is the perfect article I was looking for . Please post a lot about items related to 바카라사이트!!! I am waiting for your article. And when you are having difficulty writing articles, I think you can get a lot of help by visiting my .

  35. You should not let the title 'video game tester' fool you into thinking that this is not a job but the chance to be paid to do what you love the most. While it is true that video game testers have a lot of fun playing the games that they fell in love with at a young age, it is also a very serious job.

  36. Incredible tips and straightforward. This will be exceptionally helpful for me when I get an opportunity to begin my blog. Satta number